The Commax V3SR Surface Electromagnetic Lock 300kg with LED and Monitoring is compared with several alternative access control locks, including AutoTune Hartte MG180SR, JetWorld Hartte MG350SR, Commax Hartte MG60S, Dymo HARTTE MG280SR, and SCOT EL-600SL2. All reviewed devices are designed for secure access control integration, but they differ in holding force, presence of status monitoring and LED signaling, as well as suitability for various door types.
⚙️ The table below compares the device type, holding force, door status monitoring and LED indication features, along with recommended application scenarios.
| Comparison parameter | Commax V3SR | AutoTune Hartte MG180SR | JetWorld Hartte MG350SR | Commax Hartte MG60S | Dymo HARTTE MG280SR | SCOT EL-600SL2 | Practical significance |
|---|
| Device type | Electromagnetic lock | Electromagnetic lock | Electromagnetic lock | Electromagnetic lock | Electromagnetic lock | Electromagnetic lock | All devices use the electromagnetic locking principle for access control. |
| Holding force | 300 kg | 180 kg | 350 kg | 60 kg | 280 kg | 600 kg | The holding force determines the weight and mass of the door the lock can secure. |
| Monitoring & signaling | Yes (LED and monitoring) | Yes (LED and monitoring) | Yes (LED and monitoring) | No (basic model) | Yes (monitoring and signaling) | Yes (monitoring) | Status sensors allow transmitting lock state information to security panels. |
| Application | Commercial and residential buildings | Professional access control | Professional access control | Lightweight doors, cabinets, display cases | Single doors in commercial/residential entrances | Heavy interior and exterior doors | Models cater to different load requirements from furniture to heavy entrance doors. |
◎ The table below evaluates the suitability of the models for various user needs and use cases.
| Use case | Recommended product | Why |
|---|
| Standard entrance door in a residential or commercial building | Commax V3SR | Provides an optimal 300 kg holding force with status feedback for most standard doors. |
| Lightweight cabinets, display cases, or furniture | Commax Hartte MG60S | Compact device with a 60 kg holding force designed specifically for small, light structures. |
| Very heavy or reinforced doors | SCOT EL-600SL2 | Offers the highest holding force of 600 kg for heavy industrial or entrance groups. |
| Lighter interior doors | AutoTune Hartte MG180SR | A holding force of 180 kg is sufficient for lightweight doors without placing excessive load on fasteners. |
The Commax V3SR occupies a balanced niche among alternatives due to its 300 kg holding force, built-in monitoring, and LED indication. It outperforms smaller models like the Commax Hartte MG60S and AutoTune Hartte MG180SR in holding power while remaining lighter than heavy-duty solutions such as the SCOT EL-600SL2. It is best suited for standard doors in residential and commercial buildings where reliable locking and visual status control are required.